Daily research NYSE / NASDAQ / AMEX

balance-sheet value / Research guide

NCAV vs NTAV vs Book Value: Which Cheapness Test to Use?

Quick comparison of NCAV, NTAV, and book value so you choose the right discount metric for each stock.

Published Updated NetNetScanner research library

Published by NetNetScanner · Sources and methodology

Compare the measures in practice with NCAV stock rankings, net cash stock rankings, and net tangible asset rankings.

The three metrics at a glance

  • NCAV (net current asset value): Current assets - total liabilities. Extreme conservatism; ignores noncurrent assets.
  • NTAV (net tangible asset value): Total assets - intangibles - total liabilities. Includes PP&E but drops goodwill/patents.
  • Book value: Total assets - total liabilities. Keeps intangibles; most lenient of the three.

When to use each

  • NCAV: Distressed, cash-box, or liquidatable situations; microcaps with questionable earnings.
  • NTAV: Capital-heavy businesses where PP&E has resale value (shipping, REIT-like, certain industrials).
  • Book value: Stable franchises where intangibles are meaningful (brands, software) and balance sheet is clean.

Discount rules of thumb

Price below a reported asset measure is a research trigger. It does not establish an appropriate purchase price. A two-thirds-of-NCAV screen is one possible threshold; it still requires separate investigation of asset recovery, financing, management, and ongoing losses. NTAV and book value likewise have no universal safe discount.

Haircut guidance

Reported NCAV excludes noncurrent assets, while reported NTAV excludes goodwill and other intangible assets. Do not add intangibles back into either definition. A separate recovery scenario can adjust receivables, inventory, or property using evidence about collections and resale markets. Label those assumptions explicitly rather than presenting adjusted recoveries as the reported accounting measure.

Same company, three different asset measures

For a hypothetical company with $30 million of current assets, $50 million of total assets, $8 million of goodwill and other intangibles, $18 million of total liabilities, and 6 million ordinary shares:

Measure Total Per ordinary share
NCAV: $30m − $18m $12 million $2.00
NTAV: $50m − $8m − $18m $24 million $4.00
Book equity: $50m − $18m $32 million $5.33

At a hypothetical price of $3, the stock is below NTAV and book equity but above NCAV. Calling it a net-net solely because it trades below book value would conflate different screens.

This simplified example assumes one common share class and no separate noncontrolling or preferred interests. Check those claims, the share-count date, and currency before turning consolidated balance-sheet totals into per-share figures. The SEC's financial-statement guide provides accounting context; NCAV per share explains the denominator in more detail.

How to screen

  • Start with NCAV for net-net hunting.
  • Layer NTAV for asset-heavy names that fail NCAV but still carry tangible backing.
  • Use book value only with profitability and stability filters to avoid value traps.

Compliance note

This guide is educational and not investment advice. Do your own research or consult a professional adviser.

Continue with the Value Investing research process to put this topic in context.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is NCAV?

Current assets minus total liabilities; classic Graham net-net metric.

What is NTAV?

Total assets minus intangibles and total liabilities; useful when tangibles matter but inventories are real.

When do I use book value?

For stable, asset-heavy firms where intangibles still have value; otherwise prefer NTAV or NCAV with haircuts.